luarcdm This film is probably a success because of the discussions it is triggering. It touches something inside of us that makes us to react so violently, to argue and to try to destroy a piece or art (an expression)... I understand some of the critics related to the cinematographic composition of this film that would tend to qualify it as very poor. Indeed, some turns in the plot/characters are astonishingly odd and disappointing, like those that any person would endure during a DNA experiment or even a long space trip. In other words, this film could be a representation of what it means to bring nonsense and control-less turns into a control-freak earth. A film-test for viewers on resilience to change and openness to the unknown of our species, on earth or elsewhere, by challenging our self-inflicted expectations on cinematography.

kenny-258-703591 This had some potential; however, it missed the mark. The movie could have been way better.I also try very hard not to read into the political leanings of this movie, but it was too hard not to. It was definitely a politically driven script which makes it all the more awful and painful.

gnola Please set your expectation that you are not going to see a 100 billion dollar budget sci-fi movie and you'll get out of the movie not so unsatisfied. Good plot, the ending could have been a bit better developed

maxohballe I registered to IMDb just to be able to downvote this movie.Most critics explained pretty well what was wrong but what shocked me the most, and by far is that the "good girl" did exactly what the "bad guy" planned to do since the very beginning up until the final scenes and everyone was fine with it. On top of it, it doesn't solve any problem for Earth.It does not make any sense whatsoever. This ending made me throw up a little bit in my mouth because it was just too disgusting to swallow.I've lots of questions though ; how did this scenario got produced ? Who decided to make this happen ? Why do so many famous actors decided to go for it ? Who likes this horrible, abject waste of time ?I can't believe what I just watched.