Aristides-2 A post-horrific movie. A half century plus of Israeli-Arab life as lived mainly in Nazareth. As depicted, the gradual erosion of Arab social life move the characters from inchoate normalcy to Beckettian realism. But since violence is muted virtually throughout the five to six decades shown, this viewer was left with a strange flatness of effect since Langdon and Tati-like staging dehumanized much of what I saw because of how the director composed the shots and how he directed the actors. Perhaps he was emotionally stunted by living through some of the history shown but his reaction.....his movie.....repelled me by his tiresome, repetitive remove from it all; he never showed the day-to-day-to-year-to-year horror of it all that made the absurdity understandable. There was no "middle" to the movie.

Fuad Halwani "The Time that Remains" is by far one of the most well-made and powerful Arab movies (and specifically Palestinian) to date. Elia Suleiman tackles one of the most prominent issues in the Arab world with beautiful imagery, nostalgia, music, and the silent word.I usually do not admire having a director act in his/her own film, but Elia Suleiman is his films, they are part of him and his appearance in them as the silent observer simply attacks the emotions and makes the viewer a part of his own life. "The Time that Remains" basically chronicles the life of his mother and father and their 'silent' resistance through the turmoil of the Israeli invasion of Palestine from 1948 till today.What is so powerful about this film is that how the viewer (and especially an Arab viewer) can go through a history of conflict so smoothly with much joy and come out with a striking view of this history. Suleiman shows will all simplicity how the cause still loves, without blood, with few words, but with a lot of emotions and things to say. The choice of music (classical Arabic songs) make the viewer understand what the beauty of being an Arab is, and how this beauty is slowly fading... fading into a lack of identity.I watched Suleiman's previous film "Divine Intervention" after watching this one and realized that we do have an Arab auteur director in our midst; his playful style and cartoonish characters all the more strengthen his cause and keep on his silent resistance.A pure must-see!

Camilla Stein Sometimes, life throws at us things that over the years become too big to comprehend. Such are natural disasters, pandemic diseases, nuclear explosions, and wars.In his movie, released in 2009, Elia Suleiman sets on a journey to explore the genre of black comedy, so as to reveal to us the secret of coping with a tragedy of which the magnitude is overwhelming.It is the nature of human mind to always look for some form of normality, maybe a little static, but nevertheless, a feeling that your bases are covered, your life has a purpose and your entire existence in a certain place and at a certain time is not meaningless. This is what we, humans, do when gun battles, tanks and security surges are suddenly a persistent part of the daily routine. And this is exactly the focus of The Time That Remains. Half a century of tragedy is squeezed into an hour and a half of a laconic and precisely targeted shock therapy.Despite its smoothness and an accurately placed hint of suspense, this movie doesn't truly give you a moment of rest. There's no wallowing in self-pity here, no destructive mind blowing imagery; even the garden of executions is so well carved into the texture of the surrounding neighborhood that it appears natural despite your mind telling you that what you are looking at is a yelling contradiction to what is humanly acceptable.There's also no conflict, in a traditional sense of the word, around which the story would evolve. All there is is a deceptively distanced and only seemingly uninvolved bitterly comic narration about generations of painful struggle to remain human in a filled with nonsense reality, where even a direct participant finds himself merely an observer, trying to just be.The movie strikes as grotesque, largely satirical, very reflective and detailed. This effect doesn't wear off till the very last scene.When telling the truth becomes a taboo, the sensationalism of this movie is found in the peculiar way of drawing attention to what should not be discussed, because the subject makes us uncomfortable.Elia Suleiman resorts to various means offered by cinematography in order to break the unbreakable, to jump over the wall.There are no loud graphic scenes in this movie, nothing at all that an adult cannot handle; yet, it is heavily loaded with incredible emotions that run deep in the film's canvas, leaving you gulp for air at times.When deciding whether or not to watch this movie, don't hesitate. Just watch. And prepare lots of tissues, even if you are known for having a thick skin.

guy-bellinger As was the case for 'Divine Intervention', Elia Suleiman's former masterpiece, the viewer can't help but admire the originality of its style. What a wonderful thing that a Palestinian should be able to evoke the situation prevailing in his motherland and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict not in a full-frontal, simplistic, dogmatic way (which would be forgivable given the circumstances) but in an unexpected, humorous, quirky, poetic fashion, a little as if Harry Langdon, Buster Keaton and Jacques Tati had decided to tackle geopolitics for once. Suleiman's talent is really offbeat : contemplation in preference to action (the narrator played by Suleiman himself observes more than he acts); silence rather than significant dialog (the main protagonists hardly ever speak and those who express themselves the most are secondary characters saying only superficial things); symbolism before realism (the Israeli taxi driver lost in the turmoil of a summer storm, not knowing where he is going, not recognizing his country anymore).Occasionally very funny (the Iraqi soldier who can't find the battlefield; the gun of a tank following the coming and going of a young Palestinian in the process of taking out his trash bag and talking on his mobile phone without caring the least bit about the threat), 'The Time That remains' contains crazy gags which are a relevant reflection of the absurd atmosphere reigning in Palestine. But most of the time, the film consists in the poetic account of the odd life Palestinians are forced to live, concentrating mainly on the director's parents,a shy but loving mother and a fearless rebellious father, to whom the director pays homage. Not the type to wear his heart on his sleeve, Suleiman expresses his filial love with discretion and restraint. The scenes with his mother aged eighty and with his father dying in the car are particularly moving.'The Time That Remains' looks like no other film of any sort. Go and see it.