JohnHowardReid Robert Armstrong (Larry Doyle), Maxine Doyle (Ann), Henry Kolker (Jonas), James Burke (Marvin), Guy Usher (District Attorney Johnson), LeRoy Mason (The Eel), Dell Henderson (hotel manager), Monte Collins (Dunn), Norman Houston (Whistler), James P. Burtis (Whalen), Sam Lufkin (Weeks), Otto Fries (pawnbroker), Sam Flint (Jerome Roberts, the publisher), Stanley Blystone (waiter), Herb Vigran (fingerprint man), Frfed Kelsey, Bruce Mitchell (policemen), Harry Strang (train depot tightwad), Lee Shumway, Rollo Lloyd.Director: RAY McCAREY. Screenplay: John W. Krafft, Rollo Lloyd. Adapted by William A. Johnston from a story by Tate Finn. Photography: Harry Neumann. Film editor: Carl Pierson. Art director: E.R. Hickson. Sound recording: John A. Stransky, junior. Producer: George Yohalem. Executive producer: Trem Carr. Copyright 28 February 1935 by Monogram Pictures Corporation. U.S. release: 12 February 1935. No recorded New York opening. 67 minutes. SYNOPSIS: After being fired from his job in Chicago, a top crime reporter talks his way into the employ of a tabloid in St Louis.COMMENT: A pleasant but rather action-less little movie, spun out with loads of talk. Fortunately, the players led by live-wire Robert Armstrong and the really super-cute Maxine Doyle do manage to sustain interest. Well, even my interest anyway. But I think everyone will admit that even James Burke has a spicy role. And the really-really good news is that production values are unusually glossy by Monogram's generally rather humble standards.

jayraskin This really seems to be two movies in one. The first is a sweet romantic comedy that takes up the first 40 minutes of the film. Reporter Larry Doyle from Chicago gets $50 for breaking an important story and does too much celebrating. He ends up broke in St. Louis. He sits down at a lunch counter with beautiful Anne Oglivie (Maxine Doyle). She finds that she only has 10 cents to pay for her 20 cent coffee and donut. Larry secretly pays for her. Realizing that a young girl broke in the city could end up in trouble, Larry follows her around to help her out. Having no place to stay, he gets a hotel room for the two of them. Anne is reluctant, thinking he wants sex in return, but Larry reassures her that he's a square kind of guy. He orders an expensive $35 a day hotel suite which has two bedrooms with separate keys. He explains that Anne is as safe with him as she would be anywhere in the city.This part of the movie seems to inspired by Frank Capra's "It Happened One Night" which came out also in 1935. Suddenly with about 25 minutes left the movie turns into a more typical Monogram murder mystery. Larry, remembering that he's an investigative reporter, goes after a slippery gangster called "the Eel." As all Monogram murder mysteries are, its silly, cheap and quite a lot of fun.Robert Armstrong (King Kong, Son of Kong, Mighty Joe Young) gives a really strong performance. He's a sweet tough guy with a heart of gold. Maxine Doyle is excellent as the broke virgin in the city. Twenty years old at the time, this was one of her first starring movies. Over the next two years, in 1936 and 1937, she starred in about a dozen low budget movies and that was pretty much the end of her career. She did do some bit parts in the 1940's.Monogram generally made "C" or "D" movies. This one is actually a solid "B" movie.

MartinHafer This B-movie is from Monogram Pictures--a company known for low-budget and relatively low quality films. Now this isn't to say their films are not enjoyable--they are often VERY fun to watch--they just aren't particularly distinguished. In the case of "Mystery Men", it's obvious that the writing was poor--but somehow, despite many silly plot elements, the film was fun to watch.Robert Armstrong stars as a crime reporter. In the first of MANY irrational plot points, the local DA wants to show his appreciation for Armstrong's work...so he has a .45 caliber pistol awarded to him! Then, while he's on a trip to St. Louis, he meets a woman who is broke. Now what would you do in a situation like this? Well, you certainly would NOT pretend that she is your wife and then check into a hotel you cannot afford! Well, that is exactly what he does...and with no expectations of sex. Then, when he tries to get a job with the local paper and the prospective employer calls his old paper, what happens--yep, the old boss tells the St. Louis newspaper editor that the man in his office is a phony and the real reporter is back in Chicago!!! Huh?!? Then, when Armstrong eventually DOES get the St. Louis job anyway, he investigates a crime spree. And, when he sees the killer leaving with the money, what does he do? Yes, he pretends to be one of the gang and drives away with the loot! Can you see that none of this makes any sense? There are MANY more situations like this in the film--I am only naming a few. But, oddly, despite so many dopey moments, Armstrong manages to at least make it enjoyable and the film kept my interest...though it was a bad film from most respects.

secondtake The Mystery Man (1935)Well this is a fast hoot, and not a good movie by any means. It has a chipper tone and some comic twists, but the acting, the acting. The core idea is good--a news reporter with a thankless editor gets caught up in a story while on leave from his Chicago paper. But the St. Louis newspaper won't believe he's a reporter, and he gets stranded and eventually accused. Luckily his buddies back home help out, and even better, a pretty girl is also stranded and helpless and good for moral support and some cleverness in the nick of time. Coulda been something.It's not like 1935 is too early for a snappy, intelligent crime detective caper film. We've already had a string of absolute classics from Warner Bros. in the early 30s, and we're seeing the beginning of the "Thin Man" series with its high level of sophistication. But this is a B-movie through and through, and I guess there is only so much talent to go around. You would do better plodding through the worst of the Mr. Moto or the Charlie Chan films than this one.