MartinHafer Technically speaking, this was a good movie. It's obvious United Artists put a lot of money behind this project (and why shouldn't they, as two of the company's creators were the star of this film and his wife!). The sets and costumes were nice, the matte paintings and backgrounds were among the best I've seen in a silent and the stunts were fantastic. However, the overall package was still very weird, as there was an uncomfortably odd combination of various earlier Douglas Fairbanks films along with what looked almost like the Jennifer Jones film "The Song of Bernadette"! Odd to say the least.The film begins with a religious prologue about a young shepherdess falling from a cliff but being miraculously healed by what appears to be the Virgin Mary. Soon a religious shrine is built there.Ten years have now passed. It seems that in this South American nation, a corrupt government is now oppressing the people (just like in "The Mark of Zorro" and "Robin Hood" and "The Black Pirate" and several other Fairbanks films). Fairbanks is a bandit (it's not clear if he steal from the rich and gives to the poor...maybe he just steals) and he and his men take over a small town run by government thugs. However, despite the lovely stunt-work and women who adore him, the Gaucho is a bit of a jerk. When, as the new town's leader, he's mean to someone who has some weird disease (that looks NOTHING like any real illness). As a result, this afflicted person sneaks up on him later and deliberately infects him! And, thanks to some prayers and a re-appearance by the Virgin, the Gaucho is healed and life is good.The story is great to look at but heavy-handed and silly. My advice is first see Fairbanks' more famous films--they are better. Then, if you're curious, try this freaky film. It's good but not among his best by any standard.By the way, speaking of weird, get a load of the 'house scene'. If you see the movie, then you'll know what I mean!!

pery-1 This was hyped at the 2009 SF Silent Film Festival as dark, unconventional and more to 21st century tastes than most silent films. I found it a combination of over-the-top silliness with heavy-handed religious tedium. Perhaps it can be described as surreal. Unfortunately I did not find that entertaining. There is a bit more sexuality than in other Fairbanks films, but nothing compared to Valentino. His continual silly cigarette tricks. too-fast jumps, Velez's arms-on-hips heaving-breast stances, the house dragging scene, and the German expressionist style fake landscapes, walls that crumble at a touch, and the constant performance of miracles, take away from any feeling of reality. They say El Gaucho is the prototype for Mickey Mouse, and the movie does have a cartoon-like character, except for the religious parts. Perhaps the religious element is part of the formula to "get away with anything as long as you throw in religion". For me, it can't hold a candle to The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse or even The Eagle. Fairbanks movies that I prefer include The Mark of Zorro and The Black Pirate.

rdjeffers Monday June, 7:00pm The Paramount Theater, SeattleDouglas Fairbanks chose a swarthy Argentine anti-hero for his next-to-last silent role in The Gaucho (1927).A young shepherdess is visited by the Holy Virgin while tending her flock and a mountain shrine is built on the site. Years pass, and The City of the Miracle attracts wealth and attention. When a corrupt general known as Ruiz the Usurper (Gustave von Seyfferitz) takes over the town, they are liberated by The Gaucho.Fairbanks perennial Charles Stevens plays The Gaucho's First Lieutenant and Mary Pickford appears (literally) as The Virgin, in two cameos that are almost certainly what were originally the two-color Technicolor segments now presumed lost.

jsobre-1 This is typical 20's Fairbanks, when he was making his grand epic swashbucklers, with typical over-complicated plots. The character reminds me of the first Zorro, but this guy is harder, and nastier (even after his miraculous reform). Fairbanks was also in his mid-forties when he made it, which explains his fined-down, but still very buff, appearance.The plot is a mythical Argentina (with a tango thrown in to define the place, but it could take place anywhere, including Zorro's Early California. Fairbanks does wear an exotic costume, though.Lupe Velez' Mountain Girl is the real departure. She is feisty, for one, and swashes every bit of buckle that Fairbanks does. These sort of characters are usually the one who DOESN'T get her man; here, it is with great satisfaction that she does--a woman ahead of her times!