tavm
According to the IMDb list of Walt Disney's directorial achievements, this was the second earliest animated short he ever made (the first being Little Red Riding Hood). In this Laugh-O-Gram, we see four animals running from bricks being thrown after them by humans. The last of them, a cat, keeps appearing and disappearing at various points in this sequence. They stop at a river where three of them play music while the cat tries to catch a fish that walks out of the river and jumps away each time the cat tries to hit him with a board. I'll stop there and say that was pretty amusing as was a later sequence where some human men shoot cannon balls at the house the four animals are staying with the cat pulling a Felix and using his tail to hit one of those balls from the roof and then riding on another of them (or was it the same one? I can't remember). Pretty primitive but worth a look for anyone curious about the legendary Disney's earliest works.
MartinHafer
Okay, this cartoon is a bit on the dull side and bore few signs of future greatness--I admit it. However, compared with other cartoons of the era, it's pretty good--especially in the animation quality. Apart from having backgrounds that keep repeating themselves again and again (a cheap technique that was later often used by Hanna-Barbera), it was top-notch work. The problem to is that the script was pretty weak and wasn't all that funny of interesting. Sadly, interesting scripts generally didn't materialize in cartoons until much later. Also, this toon bore no real resemblance to the classic story of the four animals aching to become musicians...and that's a shame because it would have beat this film.
F Gwynplaine MacIntyre
"The Four Musicians of Bremen" is one of the very earliest Walt Disney cartoons, made at his first animation studio in Kansas City, Missouri. The Kansas City movies (all of them silent) are the only Disney cartoons that were actually drawn and animated by Walt Disney himself. Beginning with his Alice in Cartoonland series (created by Harman & Ising) and Mickey Mouse (created, drawn and animated by Ub Iwerks), all of the Disney studio's films were actually created by someone other than Uncle Walt himself. The Kansas City Disneys make it painfully obvious that Walt Disney's skills as a cartoonist, draughtsman and animator were extremely poor (even by the standards of 1920s animation). Disney wisely passed those jobs to craftsmen like Ub Iwerks and Hugh Harman. After relocating his studio from Kansas City to California, Disney confined his own efforts to the front office as a producer and administrator ... where he had considerable talents indeed."The Four Musicians of Bremen", like most of the Kansas City Disneys, is based on a European folktale ... in this case, the one about the four animals of Bremen (led by a donkey) who decide to "sing" but who have terrible voices. The cartoon is quite faithful to the original story, although slightly jazzed up for American audiences of the 1920s. Since the raucous animal noises made by the "musicians" are crucial to the plot (and to the comedy), it's unfortunate that this is a silent movie.Wherever possible here (and in all his Kansas City films), Disney resorts to "lazy" animation. At the climax of "The Four Musicians of Bremen", a swarm of bees chase four soldiers, who run together in a cluster (as if they were all glued to each other) so that they can be animated as a single unit (with repeating animation cels) rather than as distinct characters. The bees keep stinging the soldier in the centre of the cluster, who keeps jumping out of the group and then jumping back in again. Because the soldiers at the edge of the cluster never get stung, they never move away from the cluster ... and Disney can keep cycling the same animation cels for the entire sequence. It would be more believable (and funnier) if the bees stung each one of the soldiers in turn, but then the soldiers at the edge of the cluster would have to move individually ... which would be more expensive to animate. I find this sort of cheapjack animation very annoying: it's something that Disney moved away from very quickly, yet this "lazy" animation technique turned up again almost forty years later in the "Flintstones" cartoons. While I was watching "The Four Musicians of Bremen", I kept expecting to see the bees chase the soldiers past one tree ... the same tree, over and over and over. You know the tree I mean: the one that shows up in the background of every bottom-of-the-barrel cartoon (including the "Flintstones") when the characters pass the same tree every three seconds."The Four Musicians of Bremen" is interesting as an early example of Walt Disney's work - one of the very few examples of his OWN work - but it's not very funny and it certainly isn't attractive to look at.
