Rainey Dawn I do believe the film is a bit underrated... it's better than what the critics say it is. I will say it's your basic ghost slow burning horror-thriller story but one of the better one's I've seen. The acting is really good - super pairing with Maria Bello and Sean Bean.8/10

fishpoo Whilst on a trip to Wales, Adèlle and James's teenaged daughter goes missing and is presumed to have drowned. In her place another teenaged girl named Ebrill appears, who apparently died fifty years earlier. Through the process of trying to discover what happened to her daughter, Adèlle uncovers a disturbing secret involving the town.Most reviewers already point out that the main problem with this film is its lack of originality. I think that at its core, the film actually has a reasonably unique concept concerning an alternate reality (Anwyn - which is a sort of afterlife), but the film mostly resorts to clichéd scare tactics and fails to really make good use of its subject matter. This kicks in right from the start of the film, which opens with the main character experiencing the loss of her daughter before she is woken up suddenly and we realize that it was simply a dream (as well as a premonition of what will happen later).Unfortunately for its stars, the film gives them little to work with. With the exception of establishing for no apparent reason that Adèlle is a smoker (which is odd, considering smoking can lead to higher certificates and therefore lower box office intake), there is virtually no character development. Sean Bean is wasted, as his character James has no personality whatsoever and might as well have been played by a cardboard cut-out. Furthermore, while an oddly placed flashback suggests that Adèlle and James may have had some complicated relationship problems, they get along suspiciously well. They don't dislike each other and they don't show any affection for each other. You'd think that the fact they have a daughter together might make their relationship a little more interesting, but the two of them only have about as much chemistry as I have with my postman.One thing that the film offers that sets it out from many ordinary horror films is its setting of the Welsh countryside. Most of the film takes place by the sea and surprisingly for a film with such a title, it is a very bright horror film. The day time scenes tend to be the more interesting ones, including a scene in which a character standing dangerously close to the edge of a cliff must dodge a horde of sheep racing towards them. I can't say that I've seen that before. However, when it gets dark, we're forced to watch the standard horror scene in which a person walks around a dark place with a torch until they uncover something scary. While comedies at least have to come up with new jokes, it seems to me that there is no end to the number of times a horror film can reuse what is essentially exactly the same scene as we've already seen in countless other films.The film then makes use of another plot device I didn't need to see yet again, as Adèlle must uncover the dark and somewhat supernatural history of the town. But all the characters around her think that she's crazy and only try to get in her way. Luckily it doesn't last too long and this is another one of the film's strengths – it progresses at a nice fast pace instead of ever dwelling on the same subject for too long.My main problem with this film's first scene, in which we establish that Adèlle has a tendency to see things that turn out not to be real, is that it means that for the remainder of the film we cannot take anything at face value. So when a girl comes back from the dead, it's difficult to feel as moved by it as we perhaps should because we already know that Adèlle might have made the whole thing up in her mind. And then when James meets the girl and doesn't seem to think that this strange girl who has appeared in an otherwise fairly deserted town is a big deal (because his character is made out of cardboard), it's also hard to feel that her resurrection is in any way significant.And that for me is what weakened the film the most. It sets out to be a supernatural horror, but none of its supernatural moments pack any punch (It's far from Pinhead's entrances in the Hellraiser films). It would have been nice to be fascinated when Ebrill returns from the dead.Deep beneath the clichés is an interesting myth and a creepy story concerning a mass suicide that was encouraged by a pastor. Unfortunately while it provides some of the setup for the events of the film, it does not make up for much of the film's runtime and is mostly told through some brief flashbacks whilst a Welshman tells the story to Adèlle. It's a shame, because it was easily the most interesting part of the film for me and I would much rather have seen a film set in the mid 20th century about a mass suicide in a small Welsh town.I think that the most important thing for a filmmaker to keep in mind when making a film that deals with characters crossing between the real world and an alternate reality, is that the more real the real-life scenes feel, the more surreal and interesting the fantasy scenes will feel. Thanks to a lack of character development and its useless dream sequences, this film fails to create a clear distinction between the two realities and they just sort of blend together. Neither world is established enough to create a contrast.I don't think that the writers or the director have managed to make much out of their initial ideas here, but at least they tried and at least the film is not a sequel.

dutchchocolatecake I absolutely love this movie. I bought it several years back when it came as a Silent Hill double DVD bundle. It is similar to Silent Hill as a mother goes to the depths of the underworld to save her child. It remains a unique story in it's own right, introducing the American public to an almost Lovecraftian segment of Welsh Mythology.The acting is good. Sean Bean is always a treat. I read the user review of the author, and I am disappointed that they didn't like the way the movie turned out. I got all the ideas described and more, although it is subtle will be lost on a disengaged audience. I found the story absorbing. I sympathized with the characters. They were all complex and written very well. If you like Silent Hill, you may like this one as well.

Mike Hollis Spoiler: Fantasy sequel:The movie leaves lots open at the end. I guess after the movie finishes, the ghost father will end up helping the mother find her daughter, get her back to our reality from the dead world and then subsequently swap the possessed girl with her actual daughter and a happy ending for all at the end of the sequel. If there ever was going to be a sequel which there won't be.Sean Bean was good. I don't blame ghost girl for wanting him to be my dad. And mother was an idiot. I don't blame ghost girl for leaving her where she ended up either.The movie tries, but doesn't deliver.