Fane Jandemircadale
"Dacii" is a mediocre contribution to the peplum (aka, sword-and-sandal) genre. Massive sets and a cast of (literally) thousands do not compensate for an awkward script, unimaginative direction, and (with some exceptions) wooden acting."Dacii" was a French-Romanian co-production, with the Romanians very much the senior partner, investing an enormous amount of money and resources in the project. In Communist Romania, as in all Communist countries, film production and distribution were government monopolies, and cinema was conceived primarily not as art or entertainment, but as propaganda. "Dacii" was the visual consecration of the Romanian Communists' rapid and paradoxical evolution from servile Moscow clients to maverick National Bolshevists. It would be followed by a whole string of historical films (known collectively in Romania as "The National Epic"), whose purpose was to construct a visual national mythology which would ultimately legitimise the Communist Party and its leader, the notorious Nicolae Ceausescu, as the modern incarnation of Romania's past mythical heroes.The script is mostly static, rich in speeches and solemnities, but poor in action and weakly developed. The direction is rigid and conventional, lacking in rhythm or inspiration, unable to bring real interest even in the scenes involving a huge cast (eg, the siege of Argidava). Nicolaescu is clearly not up to the level of a Bondarchuk (or even an Aleksander Ford in "Krzyżacy").No peplum would be complete without the dubbed foreign stars; in this instance, they are three nowadays almost forgotten French actors. Georges Marchal was a French star of the early 1950s and a peplum veteran, but here he delivers a stiff and unconvincing performance as Fuscus. Marie-José Nat as Meda has neither the sheer physical beauty, nor the screen presence or acting skills that would have allowed her to make something of a part which offered little to begin with. Pierre Brice (better known for his portrayal of an Apache chieftain in numerous Karl May-inspired movies) is conventionally heroic as Severus.More notable are three Romanian performances. Amza Pellea as Decebalus displays remarkable skill, imbuing living depth to what seems to have been designed as a vehicle for nationalistic blather. Emil Botta is impressive in the small but significant part of the High Priest. And György Kovács is simply superb as Domitianus, managing to be effete and sinister without descending into outright camp."Dacii" is, of course, rife with anachronisms, anomalies, and inanities (eg, the Roman cavalry charging... a Dacian fortress!). But all these, as well as the defects outlined above, must be put into perspective. From "Cromwell" to "Braveheart" and beyond, anachronisms and inanities abound in historical epics of much greater pretension and reputation. Weak scripts, stiff direction and poor acting are par for the course in the peplum genre. "Dacii" was director Sergiu Nicolaescu's first feature film; the fact that he managed, on his first outing, to bring to completion such a complex project is perhaps more noteworthy than his failure to make it interesting.What the Western viewer may perhaps fail to appreciate is that the film is loaded with Romanian nationalistic tropes and symbols. For instance, the scene of the human sacrifice is awkwardly framed with the so-called "Sfinx of Bucegi", a natural rock formation which, when viewed from a certain angle, looks like a human head. Photographs of this view of the "Sfinx" (which would re-occur in other episodes of the "The National Epic") were ubiquitous in Romanian media (and especially school text books), and thus instantly recognisable by the intended audience. Another example is the helmet worn by Decebalus in the final battle. This is a replica of the Helmet of Cotofenesti, shown erroneously with a flat top. The original helmet was ceremonial (not worn in battle), may not even have been Dacian, preceded Decebalus by about 500 years, and had a rounded or conical top; but a reconstruction with a wrong top was, again, ubiquitous in Romanian text books.(Note for the history buff: Don't waste your time looking for the "falx dacica" in action in this movie -- it is most notable by its absence.)"Dacii" was an instant success in Romania, where it remains to this day among the most popular native movies. But abroad, where its nationalist appeal was lost (as in France, where it was released in a slightly modified form as "Les Guerriers") it sank like a stone. It was never released in the US.A bit of trivia: The massive sets and thousands of extras (courtesy of the Romanian Army) were re-used by Robert Siodmak in his last film, "Kampf um Rom". Nicolaescu, "Dacii"'s director, served as one of Siodmak's 2nd unit directors.
miliro
I wish people were less "detached" and less bored sometimes, to appreciate valuable movies for what they really are - valuable movies. As I am about to finish watching "Columna" on TV here in Bucharest, I'm thinking how lucky we are to have this fascinating history. To us, both "Dacii" and "Columna" are excellent and make very valid points as to how ancient Dacia was conquered by the Romans. I am sorry that these movies (as many other Romanian historical movies) are not easy to find in the West, as the viewer comments on here seem to indicate. (I'd initially come on here to see where they could be found, to recommend them to a friend in the West). I think they would also prove useful, providing a wealth of information and "insight" for anyone wanting to learn more about this part of the world.
valentindeak
Best fight scenes , huge masses of soldiers , very credible movie.I saw that movie when I was a child and I was very impressed . I saw again when I grew up and still impressed. I was fascinated by the story of fighting between Dacia and Rome and when I saw this movie the stories became reality. Great performance for the unforgettable actor Amza Pellea as Decebal (the king of dacians) and the best movie of Sergiu Nicolaescu. This is a super-production in the spirit of '60 movies (Spartacus , Battle for Rome). A movie with great Romanian and international actors. The movie is better than The Gladiator or other actual historical movies.
praefectus praetorio
This is really a very impressive movie, one of my favourites. And what is its major advantage? It's a deep and natural empathy for the ancient past without any need to add some artifical tricks. Music score perfectly matches with all scenes. Landscape views with marching or fighting legions are superb. Unfortunately, at least VHS record is very hard to find and DVD doesn't exist so far. There should be no doubts that this movie, as well as some other similar releases, deserve a better international recognition of fans and connoisseurs.