mbatl08 Well it would have been a whole lot better if it was presented the same way as P.U.L.S.E. Just to name a few of the problems with this video: the solos are chopped, it doesn't focus as much attention to the band as it does the audience, at times it shows clips from other shows, the style of filming was absolutely horrible, I could go on and on. A few positives: David's guitar work is terrific, the light show was great, and the backup singers were AWESOME on The Great Gig in the Sky! Overall, though, it was a classic example of a concert video with great potential being ruined by poor directing and modification for MTV. However, the CD of this concert is awesome! If you want to enjoy Delicate Sound of Thunder, I highly recommend the CD over the video. If you want a good Pink Floyd concert on video/DVD, P.U.L.S.E. is the way to go.

hillsack Oh, dear! Roger Waters was mistaken if he thought Pink Floyd would dwindle and die without him, but this album represents all that was wrong with the post-Waters Floyd. First there's 'Shine On, You Crazy Diamond', one of the more amiable soporific Floyd opuses, but their inability to hit the right pacing means it's hiccupping all over the shop here. The numbers from 'A Momentary Lapse Of Reason' are leaden and laden with morose sentimentality, and Floyd's heightened obsession with making the maximum possible impact meant the loss of subtlety and surprise (a bugbear of symphonic rock at the best of times): the songs, like the ecstatic crowd, just thunder on indelicately somewhere in the background. The mechanical 'Learning To Fly' is a clumsily overproduced tune trying to sound spacey. And what is the point of a song like 'The Dogs Of War'? The musically superior 'Us and Them', also featured here, had already made the same point some fifteen years earlier in a much more poetically succinct manner. Even the excellent 'One Of These Days' is messed up; it certainly packs a punch, but there's a dreadfully peppy, stylised 80's sound to it, and that's the problem with the whole album. Rock groups, ever fearful of being labelled as passé, sometimes do the silliest things when pandering to the fickle tastes of the zeitgeist. By that time, Prozac Floyd had descended to the visual dork level of a Howard Jones, with the session men sporting ridiculous mullets and straining out jazzed up sax and guitar versions of the tunes which made Floyd great, accompanied by David Gilmour's silly and irksome growling. The point of this album? Another buck in the billfold.

ccthemovieman-1 The concert included some of the most innovative "light shows" I've ever seen in a musical venue. I saw it on tape so I'm sure it looks even better on DVD. I think the visuals were better than the music, to be frank. I didn't find the songs to be anything special. They weren't bad, but nothing I would want to hear over and over. Perhaps being stoned would be the ticket but those days are long over. Speaking of the "old days," I found some of the lyrics in here so '60s-ish with the irreverence of the period that it turned me off. Those ultra-Liberal days are over, too. It didn't inspire me to hear these songs again. "Hey, teacher....leave them kids alone!" should be changed to "Hey, guys, give those lyrics a rest! (or, "Hey, guys - learn some grammar!")

pbrugalett This (short of "The Wall") is the best Pink Floyd video experience. The long guitar and sax solos, along with eye-catching video and three luscious ladies singing backup, Money, Comfortably Numb, Us and Them, Wish You Were Here, Run Like Hell, plus more! What more could you want? Where's the DVD?