George Clarke Lets face it, the glory days of our Hong Kong action heroes such as Jackie Chan, Sammo Hung, Yuen Biao, Jet Lee and such are gone... Heck, they don't even make them the same anymore, with each new film becoming more and more Hollywood-ised which was part of the reason we loved them in the first place - gritty originality!And with respect to all my heroes, it is nice to see a host of them standing proud alongside the next generation of action stars - namely, the handsome Philip Ng and Andy On.Once Upon A Time In Shanghai brings these great 2 talents together under the wing of the fantastic Wong Jing, amazing Yuen Woo Ping and many more to give us an epic martial arts feature!Sharing the screen is the always incredible Sammo Hung, Yuen Cheung Yan, Chen Kwan Tai to name but a few, each gaining a bout of screen action without ever stealing the limelight from the ass kicking Philip Ng.Beautifully shot and directed, simple and hard hitting, OUATIS is worthy of a place in any kung fu film fans collection!!

MartinHafer I love a good martial arts film but too often they end up disappointing me. Often, the action is, to put it charitably, really lame--with punches and kicks that obviously do not connect and ridiculous sound effects that are laughable. And, in a few cases, I've seen films that feature some amazingly skilled fighting but the story is paper-thin. Fortunately, with "Once Upon a Time in Shanghai", you have a film that manages to do both--with some of the best and most brutal fighting you'll ever see as well as an interesting story.This film is set in Shanghai in 1930 and is done in black & white (with a few artistic colors used very sparingly and artistically). If you are a retired history teacher like me, you'll be thrilled and disappointed by this. The cars and some of the costumes really are not from the right period --and the picky history teacher in me noticed that! But, I do appreciate how the film has a historical context and is based somewhat on events of the day. Back in 1930, Shanghai was a pretty wild town--with gangs and drugs and the like which you see in the film. But what makes this interesting historically is that the Japanese are also in the movie and are clearly villains. In real life, Japan would soon begin a full scale invasion of China that would last over a decade. Most westerners have forgotten about this horrible period in Chinese history (many millions were killed) but the filmmakers haven't nor have the Chinese. And, making them the villains clearly is something that would appeal to Chinese audiences--especially in the finale when Ma screams "Get the hell out of China!!". While there is still a lot of animosity between the nations today despite efforts by both governments over the years to improve relations and we can only hope this continues.As for the story, Ma (Philip Ng) arrives penniless in this big town and needs work. However, he and his fellow villagers didn't realize that Shanghai was a really rough place--with rival gangs running the streets. Not surprisingly, soon the nice newcomers are caught up in the violence of the streets. The only local who seems decent is an odd character played by Sammo Hung (a frequent collaborator with Jackie Chan)--and Ma inexplicably falls for the man's incredibly grouchy daughter. However, this romance doesn't have much time to blossom because of all the violence between rival gangs. One of these thugs, Long Qi (Andy On), is amazingly tough--and his martial arts skills are insanely good. And soon he and Ma end up coming up against each other. Here is where the film gets really good. Instead of Long Qi killing Ma or vice-versa, the pair are so evenly matched that they actually become friends. But Ma is a good soul and manages to not only stay pure of heart but become almost like Long Qi's brother. So everyone lives happily ever after, right?! Nah...this IS a martial arts film and soon the really bad bad-guys arrive--and the Japanese are not about to let some gangs or some country bumpkin like Ma stand in their way.What's next? Watch the film for yourself---you won't be disappointed. As I mentioned above, the fight sequences are amazing...no,...they are BRILLIANT. Intense, fast, highly skilled and insane are all words that come to mind. Plus, while the heroes are a bit too super-human (they can manage to STILL hang on after 137934 stab wounds!!), the fight sequences themselves don't appear too super-human! There are very, very few "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" sorts of wire-fu techniques in this film and I appreciate this. Yes, I know some of you readers love these--I still prefer the more realistic action sequences like you'll see in films like this as well as the Street Fighter series (with Sonny Chiba), the Gina Carano films as well as "Ip Man".Now all this sounds like I am super-excited about this film. Well, I am...though I have a few reservations. The back story is a bit weak (it involves a bracelet and a promise to mother) and unnecessary. Additionally using the 'Once Upon a Time in' part of the title is a problem since so many good and bad films have used this in their titles--such as "Once Upon a Time in the West", "Once Upon a Time in Mexico", "Once Upon a Time in Vietnam", "Once Upon a Time in China" (1, 2 and 3) and many more--and none of these films have anything to do with each other and can confuse viewers!! Still, Ching-Po Wong has crafted a fine action film--and one of the best ones I've seen in recent memory.

timfongmk There wasn't much local buzz for OUATIS and if the short release run is any indication, folks in Hong Kong just don't seem to care about it. What a shame, because there is so much martial art talent at the helm.What is also a shame, is how underwhelmed I felt when the credits rolled.I was initially attracted to up-and-coming talent that was presented as the face of this film's marketing. The pairing of dark horse Philip Ng and underdog Andy On intrigued me. They've both had minor to secondary roles in many other films that lent a glimpse of their talents. Could this finally be the big break for them to to join the ranks of Hong Kong martial arts stardom? The director was Wong Ching Po, who has gained minor fame in art-house circles with his frequently unusual, sometimes violent, but always interesting takes on popular genres. How would he approach the old chop socky genre? The involvement of Sammo Hung and Yuen Woo Ping's further escalated my curiosity. Two pillar directors and choreographers of the genre, working with a fresh director, spotlighting two able young men who have clear ability but not yet chance to shine? Could such a fresh combination result in anything short of exciting? Turns out, it fell short by quite a stretch, actually.Let's start with the script. There's no hiding it was penned by Wong Jing. The man who, over the eons of Hong Kong film history, has written, directed, and produced a vast body of the most locally definitive but simultaneously most unbearable garbage ever put on celluloid man has ever seen. Fortunately, he restrains from unloading his bag of wacky fart jokes and idiotic schtick here, and keeps the story fairly straight forward and on track.Unfortunately, this also translates into a story so conservative, so safe, it might as well have been ripped from the pages of an archetype textbook. Now, this might be unfair criticism, because old fashioned kung fu movies—which OUATIS styles itself after—never had elaborate plots or deep characters. Those old movies also often had silly dialogue, mischievous situations, and whimsical choreography that blended into a cohesive whole. That was back then however, and expectations have changed since.The plot is presented as stoic and occasionally dramatic, but this angle is at odds with the overproduced action sequences and awkward, naive humor injected throughout. The resulting mix is choppy and transitions happen abruptly. It doesn't help that the dialogue itself is heavily stilted. Narrative shortcuts such as fluffy montages and poorly chosen events employed to develop a character keep the story shallow. The lack of emotional engagement leads to hollow, unearned catharsis at the end. Factors of believability, such as the use of long-knives where guns should be or On having less than 10 henchmen when he owns half the city, are sacrifices made for the sake of the action.The actors make do with what they can, but being limited by the script there's little room here for anyone to truly shine beside On, who receives abundant screen-time to verbalize and terrorize. Sadly, On seem to be dubbed out of his native tongue, affecting his delivery. He compensates with body language that effectively portrays his character. Ng, playing a shy country boy, doesn't have as much dialogue as On, but being the protagonist means a lot of screen time, which he fills earnestly with facial and body language. His slight stiffness and obvious introversion fits his role and services the thin plot. Michelle Hu and Jiang Luxia, who play respective love interests of the leads, manage to bring a surprising amount of vibrancy into their scenes with admirable performances.What is readily apparent as the film progresses is the limited budget. The sets appear thinly decorated, sparse, and empty. Most jarring is the ghost town streets of Shanghai, which is unconvincingly explained away by a character by gang warfare. Moreover, the cinematography employs a "hard" digital look with a blatant color filter that undermines the period setting and compounds the sense of cheapness. The low-key sound design is unable to mask the visual shortcomings. None of these technicalities usually matters for an action film but the glossy way the film chooses to present itself makes such issues glaring.Then there are the fights. Thanks to the skilled martial artists in the cast, they have a manic, explosive energy that is as ferocious as anything the industry has ever made. Yet the choreography and camera work can be hit or miss, sometimes blurring brawls into a slurry of indistinguishable chicken slaps. The extreme under-cranking of certain portions hurt the fights more than it helps. Too many blows are exchanged, but not enough of them are memorable, and occasionally the camera runs out of ideas on how to spice up the action. Nowhere is this more evident than the final fight, which despite pitching Ng against a string of opponents with different skills and weapons, could have benefited by being shortened.The vets on this project have seen better days, though their effort is evident. Wong is disappointingly conservative in his direction, and has not pushed the creative boundaries as he has done for other genres. A stronger script would have benefited the production. The shining beacons here are the two leads, who excel in both their roles and the demanding combat, and the two supporting actresses, who charm and captivate despite their short screen time. Together their chemistry has elevated the film to a standard it could not have otherwise achieved. Don't get me wrong, OUATIS is not a bad movie. Yet it is a Hong Kong martial arts movie released in 2014, with all the baggage that implies. When they only release once in a blue moon, I have inflated expectations for such flicks to build upon the genre's glorious legacy. As such, OUATIS's crime is being merely average.

caseymoviemania Well-staged fight sequences and Philip Ng's fairly charismatic performance are the saving grace in this elegantly stylish but hollow martial arts movie.Chang Cheh's BOXER FROM SHANTUNG (1972) was one of Shaw Brothers' most popular hits among all martial arts classics that best remembered for then-young martial arts star Chen Kuan-Tai playing the title role, Ma Yongzhen (also the movie's Chinese title). Then in 1997, director Corey Yuen attempted to remake the movie under the title of HERO (no, not that HERO starring Jet Li) with Takeshi Kaneshiro in the title role (yikes!). But that movie failed to make an impression at the box office. Now, director Wong Ching-Po made his own attempt to remake BOXER FROM SHANTUNG with ONCE UPON A TIME IN SHANGHAI.WHAT IS IT ALL ABOUT?Philip Ng plays Ma Yongzhen, a young labourer from Shantung, arrives at the prosperous city of Shanghai trying to earn some living. One day, he meets Long Qi (Andy On), a rising gangster and boss of the Paradise Club who is determined to conquer Shanghai. Long Qi is particularly impressed with Ma's amazing martial arts skills and eventually hires him to work at his club. Both of them become best friends. Meanwhile, the Japanese government collaborates with Long's nemesis, the Axe Fraternity gang (Chen Kuan-Tai, Yuen Cheung-Yan, Fung Hak-On) for drug trafficking business and eliminates Long at all cost.THE GOOD STUFFLikewise, Wong Ching-Po's direction is stylish while Yuen Woo-Ping's kinetic action choreography is impressive. Despite favoring over choppy camera-work and slow-motion effect for enhancement purpose, rest assured that the fight sequence is exhilarating and fluid enough to keep the martial arts fans happy.Up-and-coming actor Philip Ng gives a fairly charismatic performance as Ma Yongzhen. His well-toned physique, agility as well as his energetic fighting skills immediately reminds me of the late Bruce Lee. As Long Qi, Andy On displays his usual good-looking charm and cocky swagger while his fighting prowess is as impressive as always.MOST MEMORABLE MOMENT(S)The climactic fight sequence beginning with Ma Yongzhen taking down a group of axe-wielding gang, before proceed to square off against the three Axe Fraternity gang leaders (Chen Kuan-Tai, Yuen Cheung-Yan, Fung Hak-On), and finally goes head-to-head against two Japanese fighters one who carries sai and shuriken, and another with a katana).THE BAD STUFFLike (all) Wong Ching-Po's movies in the past, ONCE UPON A TIME IN SHANGHAI is sadly all style but little substance. Despite the familiar but engaging premise, his overall execution feels hollow. It doesn't help when Wong Jing's screenplay is lack of compelling depth to justify the entire movie. Even his added theme of brotherhood between Ma Yongzhen and Long Qi feels superficial.FINAL WORDSAlthough ONCE UPON A TIME IN SHANGHAI doesn't exactly lives up to its fullest potential, the movie is nevertheless a fairly engaging old-school martial arts movie worth watching for.