bob-1135 What a load of incomprehensible claptrap! Ian McKellen is a very good actor but this was full of very good actors that were not even given one minutes screen time. It is hailed as the mystery of his last case - what last case? There was no mystery as to what happened. And as for Holmes visiting a remarkable undamaged Nagasaki only two years after the atomic bomb - what? In fact you could have cut the whole Japanese content and made not a jot of difference to the film. This was just a shabby attempt to lure people using the Sherlock Holmes angle, and it turned into a maudlin heap of nothing.

marldurn My first attempt at watching this movie never got off the ground, so I sort of wrote it off as not worth it. Later another opportunity came along, so I decided to give it a second chance. I must say that as the movie progressed it drew me in more & more. As the ending neared, the story felt so real & heartwarming...this made me very glad that I had decided to watch it after all.

Korena Hayes The opening scene of Mr. Holmes is affecting, quirky and memorable, albeit in a quiet and subtle way. It's a portent of things to come. As one would expect with a film with Sherlock Holmes as the title character, off-hand utterances and seemingly random, passing moments are pregnant with meaning and possibilities that are not apparent at first, or even third glance. Not, that is, unless you happen to have (super) powers of observation, which Mr. Holmes does, in excess. The comment made in this opening scene refers to bees and wasps... specifically their ongoing contentious relationship in nature. It all comes back around in the end, after a quietly rollicking, tender and affecting story which outlines the later winter of a cleverly hybridized version of the life of this famous detective.Everything about this production is top notch, from the writing and acting to the cinematography, set design and costumes. It's Ian McKellen's performance that centers the entire thing though, like a sun centers a solar system... with gravity and brilliance. Of course, you pretty much expect genius level work from an actor like McKellen but seeing him in action here is a sublime pleasure. Some actors make acting look easy. McKellen is one of the rare actors that makes you forget he's acting and transports you to a dimension of total immersion where you really feel like you're a fly on the wall of these characters' lives. Everyone around him is also superb here, especially his three main co-stars, Laura Linnney, Hattie Morahan and Milo Parker, who plays Roger, the young son of his housekeeper and steals many of the scenes here. Holmes and Roger forge a genuine and touching friendship that in many ways is the heart of the film. Many actors, I'm sure, would be a bit frazzled by the prospect of trying to keep up with a thespian of such legendary stature and renown, but Milo Parker seems to take it in stride and gives as good as he gets. It's fun to watch.Also, as you would expect in any story about Sherlock Holmes, there is a great mystery... accentuated by Mr. Holmes' advancing age and the mental decline that sometimes accompanies the process of growing older. It's a great dramatic device that the screenwriter employs expertly. The dialogue is witty, understated, intelligent and also echoes the mystery as it unfolds. The story folds back in on itself and jumps through the looking glass in a couple of interesting ways, with Holmes here being an amalgam version of his fictional self married to an alternate universe version where he is an actual historical figure, who has been immortalized in story form by Watson. We are treated to Sherlock Holmes standing in line for and then attending a filmed version of one of his real cases, that has been fictionalized then projected on a screen while he watches... in order to help stir his memory of the real case. Wow.Fair warning - this is a quiet and somewhat "slow" film. It's never boring though. If you are into explosions, car chases, loud music, etc. in your cinematic fare, you won't find it here. What you WILL find is top notch writing and acting. This is a film for people who love movies that make them think and feel deeply. It's not confusing or hard to follow, but you do need to pay attention since things that seem like small insignificant details, end up being crucial to the overall narrative and where the characters end up. It's an exceptional piece of work and one of the best films of 2015.

bzbee-39855 Never have I seen such an insult to my favorite character, Sherlock Holmes. An absolute nonsense of a movie riding a great name. There should be a criminal case against a director and producers of this disgusting crap. Please never ever see this movie if you have any respect for the detective. I gave a resounding 1 only because 0 is not available. The Movie is just too damn slow. Nothing seems to be happening at all in the entirety of the movie. Music is too awful and it feels like the eternity while I was trying to watch it.Overall, this movie is only good if you are trying to commit suicide or playing a prank on your friend. Or, maybe it should only be played in old homes. Just simply a horrible movie.