ombelinemonteils
I liked this film even if I would not go to see it normally. I mean, this is just not the type,of film that I like, it's too realistic and I prefer thrillers or fantasy films.
But it was a good surprise, the plot is well-directed and I have nothing to say about the actors' game. This film tells us the story of Angie, a single mother who will lose her job after an act of sexual harassment. She will decide to launch her own firm with the help of Rose, her friend and accolyte.
I liked the contrast between the two : when Angie is short-tempered and shows her dark side, Rose is more down-to-earth and is deeply nice.
Well, I liked this film but it was a little bit slow I think, like a sort of floating in "action"... And some of the "dialogues" were here just for the fitting of scenes which were empty of action. Most of the time, it was interesting but they were moments which were quite boring and some of them were just completely deadly-boring. But it was a good film, it opened my eyes on things that I didn't know. This film was quite interesting even if there were useless scenes.
I recommend it for people who are interested on this theme but don't go if it's not a subject that you're interested in, because it's much socially and politically engaged, it's not a criticism, but sometimes it was difficult to follow the story because I didn't understand the social context. It was good, nothing more, nothing less. It was not vibrant, I didn't feel my blood burning in my veins, it was just good but I'm not an expert.
So I think if you know the news and if you are interested in this theme, go !
stensson
There's a new exploited class in the Western world. The illegal immigrants. Since they've got no papers, they will take any work, any wage, any risks. And there are people who are just too eager to help them.The main person here is fired from a recruiting agency. She starts her own and also starts to exploit people like she's been exploited. The free world means almost slavery, since people without papers have no rights. But those who provide companies with such labour force can easily become the victims in this perverted order.Another Ken Loach movie which put the unpleasant questions. And gives the unpleasant answers.
Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
That film has to be seen all over the world. It shows how in our globalized world the migration of people is perfectly organized and managed outside all legality with the accomplice-ship and cooperation of most governments or national services in the western countries concerned by these migrations. Here London, England. The volunteers (!?!) are essentially coming from the European Community (Poland) but also non members states from eastern Europe (Ukraine) and some countries going through a crisis like Iran and Iraq. The human beings are cattle as soon as they put their first toe in the system. They pay heftily for their passage first, just like the Jewish community had to pay for the passage of the Jews who were deported to Auschwitz. Then they will be exploited at two levels. First by the skyrocketing rents they pay for one fourth of a room or one fifth of a caravan. Second they will get some work every morning for the day and with no certitude of anything: no contract, no health insurance, no guaranteed payment of the miserable salary, no guaranteed schooling for the children. Everything is done outside any official declaration, evading taxes and all controls. And no serious service is doing anything to find out and bring things back in line. But the worst part is, though some men are behind this kind of slave market, the main flesh-eating character is a white woman, a false blonde, divorced with an 11 year old son abandoned to her own parents. She has a black associate who will finally drop out when the other trespasses beyond the narrow line between exploitation and slavery on one side and cattle- or even garbage-processing on the other. One day she will call immigration authorities to report a clandestine camp in order to get it emptied for her load of slaves that is arriving on the following morning. The black woman will be replaced and the whole forced-labor merry-go-round will start again and amplify its operation. The only advantage of being exploited by a woman is that young males will have to perform some personal service to the female slave-manager to get work on the following day. A film to be seen urgently. I was divinely surprised by the causticity of Ken Loach I was considering as slightly tamed before seeing this film. He can still bite, the old pit-bull.Dr Jacques COULARDEAU, University Paris Dauphine, University Paris 1 Pantheon Sorbonne & University Versailles Saint Quentin en Yvelines
tiana90_9
I often feel like giving a film a ten somehow weakens the review and arguments but in my humble opinion this latest work from Ken Loach is absolutely spot on! The element I applaud the most is its nuances and subtlety. Nothing is black and white, the characters are complex and display at times total disregard for humanity and at others touching empathy, thereby making a stronger point of the complexity of the situation at hand. The plot is relatively simple, but small exchanges between the characters that seem irrelevant bring a great deal of humanity to the film. Kierston Wavering is absolutely magnificent as Angie and every single other "actor" (professional or not) featured is spot on. A moving, honest, brave yet depressing masterpiece!