Horst in Translation ([email protected])
This is a 7-minute short film from roughly 60 years ago. The first short film with this character won an Academy Award in the Best Animated Short category, so they decided to follow it up with more. According to IMDb, this is the fourth entry and also the second most successful. Itw as the only other one that managed an Academy Award nomination (lost to Magoo) and even won a BAFTA. I have to say this surprises me a bit. Even if the action is not entirely childish, I feel that the constant noise and idea of him making sounds instead of speaking is really only one that could entertain children. Especially in the long run. In my opinion, that's an idea that gets old pretty quickly and loses all its charm after the first or second short movie. Anyway, our hero gets abducted to space and the aliens mistakenly think noises are the way that citizens of the Earth are speaking, so they adapt to that and in the end everybody is making McBoingBoing noises. Also I don't think calling the alien planet Moo (almost like moon) is the most creative idea. The director and writer is once again Robert Cannon, a prolific animator and filmmaker from the 1930s to the 1950s. This one here is certainly not among his best work. Not recommended.