binapiraeus Well, don't let the title lead you astray - this murder plot is, though complicated and twisted enough, far from perfect in the way of logic, because the authors just hide too many facts, present us more suspects than Chandler and scatter more red herrings than Agatha Christie... But it certainly IS fun guessing all the way (and Nikki's idea isn't even bad; it MIGHT have been the solution just as well!), although I doubt if many viewers will really find the murderer at last.Anyway, this movie, the third one where Ralph Bellamy plays 'Ellery Queen', differs from the previous ones in a welcome way: it takes things less serious and 'allows' some jokes to be thrown in. So you can really prepare yourself for an enjoyable 'whodunit' with moments of suspense as well as fun!

bkoganbing Ralph Bellamy as Ellery Queen is given some really snappy dialog with girl Friday Margaret Lindsay in Ellery Queen And The Perfect Crime. If the film had some MGM like production values this could have passed for a Thin Man film.The deceased here is Douglass Dumbrille a rather ruthless businessman who sold some bad stock to a lot of investors and then sold short, making a pile while others went bankrupt. One of those H.B. Warner who is the father of Linda Hayes and who is engaged to Dumbrille's son John Beal.The Queen family gets involved when Beal uses his friend Bellamy to help the Warner family out financially at an estate sale when the family goes bust. Of course Inspector Queen gets involved when Dumbrille is found dead.Besides those already mentioned, in the cast also are Warner's sister Spring Byington and her shyster boyfriend lawyer Sidney Blackmer and her pet monkey. The monkey dies as well and that finally unravels the mystery.This is a different Spring Byington than you are used to. She and Blackmer are all kinds of concerned about the disappearance of the family fortune and the downgraded lifestyle Spring will have to live.As for the solution all I can say is that a certain truism that has grown up around mystery novels is actually followed here.Bellamy and Lindsay turn in some nice performances as junior league Nick and Nora Charles and that's worth seeing.

gridoon2018 The owner of a company that's about to get destroyed by a storm manages to sell his stocks just before the word gets out; he wins, every other shareholder goes broke. When he is later found dead in his study with a dagger in his hand, Inspector Queen suspects that it may not be suicide, as it appears at first glance, but murder. The chief suspects are one of the shareholders who was forced to sell his house after the disaster, the dead man's lawyer, and the dead man's son, who disapproved of his father's immorality. That last suspect also happens to be a friend of Ellery Queen, who tries to solve the case in order to clear him. But he doesn't try very hard - he only figures out ONE thing about the entire case. Ellery is almost like a guest star in his own movie, and even the joyful Nikki Porter gets sidelined for much of the time. However, the story has some still-topical touches (men who destroy lives in the name of financial gain are certainly no less of a problem in 2011 than they were in 1941), and the solution fits two basic criteria of any mystery tale: a) it is surprising, b) it makes sense. ** out of 4.

Loring Ivanick There have been tons of Ellery Queens over the years in the movies and on TV and Ralph Bellamy does an admirable job in this flick. There's a lot of humor in the film. Spring Byington as a dotty matron who thinks more of her pet monkey than her family is a lot of fun, though you're never quite sure if she is as dotty as she seems. Bellamy is unflappable, jaunty and confident in the title role. His relationship and repartee with his secretary are delightful. There's a very funny scene with Ellery at an auction of the contents of a country house. The mystery isn't a bad one, though there's a good chance you will eliminate enough suspects on your own to figure out whodunnit. That won't take away from the fun of viewing. If you like the Falcon series with George Sanders and Tom Conway, you'll probably enjoy this, if you can find it. I have a copy only because I caught it on TV once and taped it. Someone ought to restore the print and issue it on DVD so everyone can enjoy Bellamy in a fine comedy-mystery role.