TheLittleSongbird
That does seem to be the general consensus regarding 'The Choir' and cannot disagree. Just for the record, these are my own thoughts written in this review, having read no reviews prior to seeing 'The Choir' and reading very few afterwards.Considering the cast, which is a great one (who can argue with Dustin Hoffmann and Kathy Bates?), 'The Choir' had real potential to be great, and should have been. Plus classical/choral music is very much prominent, and as somebody who adores both classical music and choral music and who has a lot of experience singing in choirs (having sung in professional-standard choirs since the age of 12 and featuring in eight recordings with various choirs over twelve years) that was a real treat for me.It is a shame that 'The Choir' didn't live up to the potential it had. Not a bad film by all means, but it could and should have been much better. The best thing about it is the music which is absolutely exceptional, so much so that it is what makes up more than one star of the average rating given by me.Lovely use of "Pie Jesu" (usually sung by a soprano but suits a treble just fine too) from Faure's 'Requiem', one of the masterworks in the choral repertoire. There is also a nice and healthy dose of Handel and brief but interesting use of Tallis' "Spem in Alium", a very long and difficult piece, 40 parts with 8 choirs with 5 voice parts in each, and when performing it with London Bach Choir it only just about came together in performance.Garrett Wareing is surprisingly good in the lead role, instead of being over-eager or overly cute he underplays while still being engaged it in. Dustin Hoffmann's character is underwritten but he brings gravitas and dignity, which is more than the character deserved. Eddie Izzard is in a role far removed from his usual stuff and does remarkably well, he is remarkably subtle when he could have over-compensated and makes much of what he has. The best lines and meatiest material belongs to Kathy Bates, and she clearly enjoys it and herself too. Debra Winger is finely dependable. Again, while the cast deserved better the actors do so well with what they had that they too bumped up the rating more than one star.A visually lovely film too, not expansive or cinematic but beautifully shot and with settings that suit the film perfectly.However, Giraud's direction while competent is routine, could have done much more with a great setting that could have been unique if done with more confidence. The story and script let things down considerably, like the music and cast each bumped up the average rating by more than one star the story and script each bumps it down one than one star. Personally do think that the over-familiarity and predictability of the story is a big problem, maybe it was hard not to be given the subject matter but there is nothing new here, with every plot twist sign-posted, and the emotional elements are often over-egged.Honestly, to me, it was like Giraud or the writers didn't have their hearts in it, which means that despite the music and the efforts of the cast that the film story-wise is nowhere near as interesting as ought and instead feels both rushed and dull, especially in the last 30 minutes. The last half and hour could easily have been inspiring, moving and uplifting but was neither, being too contrived and over-sentimentalised, the subplot adds nothing and can be seen from miles away.Frequently, the script is half-baked, underwritten and under-cooked and doesn't develop the characters at all in any point in the film. Hoffmann's character is particularly wronged, and in good hands it was a character that even when stereotypical could have been interesting, that it was amazing that Hoffmann actually managed to do anything with it, signs of a great actor, something that he has proved many times over the years.Renditions of the music varies. "Pie Jesu" is suitably angelic, while on the other end of the spectrum the "Hallelujah Chorus" is butchered with a lot of flatness and lack of unity, though the editing of the piece does deserve a huge part of the blame too.Overall, the cast and music, and to a lesser extent the production values, are very well, but the story, script and development of characters are severely wanting. 5/10 Bethany Cox
SnoopyStyle
Stet Tate is tough and living with his struggling single mom. His teacher tries to get him to audition for Carvelle (Dustin Hoffman) but he takes off only to find his mother had died. His biological father Gerard Owens (Josh Lucas) would rather keep him a secret from his family. Gerard puts him in the boarding school National Boychoir Academy run by the headmistress (Kathy Bates) and choir master Carvelle. Drake (Eddie Izzard) is infuriated by the lowering of entrance standards. However, Stet's natural singing talents and drive put him in the touring group. Soon, he's in conflict with Devon, the star of the group.Hoffman takes a similar tack as Whiplash but ends up being more like Mr. Holland. The young lead shows some capabilities but it may be asking too much. It's also may be asking too much to make choir singing compelling. It does a relatively good job to make this particular competitive world interesting but choir singing is not exactly toe tapping. Overall, it works up to a point.
Gordon-11
This film tells the story of a 11 years old boy who lost his single mother in a traffic accident. He is sent to a prestigious boys' choir school because of his obvious talent, where he is mentored by a strict headmaster."Boychoir" reminds me of "Whiplash", but it has more because of the emotional element. We see a boy who squanders his talent through his uncooperative behaviour. Yet, the headmaster has a way to help him develop motivation to be better. The choirs are very pleasant to listen to. The ending is quite touching, I find it joyful that the boy can have a new life. I enjoyed watching "Boychoir".
